Theater review
MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING
Two hours and 20 minutes, with one intermission. At the Winter Garden Theatre, 1634 Broadway.
Sigh no more, ladies. Sigh no more.
Whoop instead. Because Broadway has been hit by a wallop of fun — and an avalanche of confetti — courtesy of the preposterously enjoyable revival of “Much Ado About Nothing” that opened Thursday night at the Winter Garden Theatre.
William Shakespeare’s comedy, which remarkably hasn’t been on Broadway since the mid-1980s, always ends with a wedding. But this raucous party of a production, starring Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell, changes up the itinerary a tad: Boozy reception first, nuptials later.
As audiences are filing in, a group of girls dance in the aisles to rev up the room as Playbill-wielding ushers dodge them like waiters at Per Se. “Pump Up the Jam” blares, and Mason Alexander Park, as the sassy Margaret, begins the play singing a ballad version of “Tell It To My Heart.”
Its starting lyric might be one of director Jamie Lloyd’s guiding mantras: “I feel the night explode when we’re together.”
The other one is just plain “much.” His “Much Ado” shows no restraint whatsoever. Why bother?
Tiny pieces of pink paper cascade from the roof for almost the entire runtime. The stage is covered in the stuff. And during this “My Little Pony” blizzard, smartass bachelor Benedick (Hiddleston) rolls into town with his rowdy buds Claudio (James Phoon) and Don Pedro (Gerald Kyd) to the Beastie Boys’ “(You Gotta) Fight for Your Right (To Party!).”
At the Messina home of Leonato (Forbes Masson) and his daughter Hero (Mara Huf), Benedick beelines right to his usual tart-tongued sparring partner Beatrice (Atwell) and they’re back to trading delicious barbs.
“I wonder that you will still be talking, Signior Benedick,” she snipes at her frenemy. “Nobody marks you.”
Hiddleston shoots back at his fellow Marvel Cinematic Universe star, “My lady disdain, are you yet living?”
She is. And this “Much Ado” pulses with life, too.
Because Lloyd and his actors break the fourth wall with abandon, the witty insults get a louder response than usual. That back-and-forth with ticket-buyers and the club aesthetic blows some of the prestige off a play that was not written to be prestigious in the first place. We’re not quite at a taping of “Maury,” but the crowd is certainly more shaken up than at Shakespeare in the Park.
Hiddleston especially delivers one of the best Bard performances on Broadway in ages — perhaps since the duo of “Twelfth Night” and “Richard III” from London’s Globe Theatre more than a decade ago. The actor is impeccable — at once a powerful leading man and your funniest friend from college. And he finds surprising intimacy in the former home of “Mamma Mia!” and “Back to the Future.” Certainly more than George Clooney managed.
And the dastardly Lloyd really puts his star through the wringer. Hiddleston athletically rolls all over the ground, dances constantly and ably like he did in the movie “The Life of Chuck,” dons a huge puppy head from “The Masked Singer” (or a furry convention, up to you) and croons a cover of “I Want it That Way” by the Backstreet Boys.
There is a fantastic, highly Lloydian bit in which Atwell and Hiddleston talk to cardboard cutouts of their Marvel characters, Loki and Peggy Carter.
But none of that candy would go down nearly as well if he wasn’t so exceptionally gifted with classical language. Beatrice and Benedick are the forebears of all hate-into-love romances, and when the duo finally realize what we all know to be true — that they’re mad for each other — the actors are serenely beautiful and emotional. It’s one of the only quiet scenes. The requisite post-dessert slow dance.
Atwell’s terrific, too. In a metallic jumpsuit (Soutra Gilmour did the set and costumes), she makes a marvelously contemporary Beatrice with the effervescence and martini-glass attitude of a fashion model. The duo smolder together.
Other than Hiddleston, the rest of the cast are all making their Broadway debuts. And I’m relieved they didn’t swap them out for Americans, because each turn is one to treasure.
As young buck Claudio, who’s in love with Leonato’s daughter Hero, Phoon has One Direction charisma. And playing his future father-in-law, who gets the Leon’s share of the drama, Masson makes uncommon sense of what can be jarringly angry and hate-filled scenes in the second act of an otherwise mirthful comedy. They’re still a shock, but having him swig from a flask is a smart explanation for his frightening ire.
Another inspired move is having Tim Steed play the villain Don John as Disney campy rather than an uber-serious Iago who got lost. The role was a famously embarrassing one for Keanu Reeves onscreen, and he’s been mocked for his overacting his entire career. The part’s an easy trap. So, rather than try to embody evil, Steed piles on the foppery, and the baddie’s abrupt exit is turned into a very funny joke.
The script has also been cut in crafty ways that will bother no reasonable person.
Except perhaps purists — those who prefer their Shakespeare with a side of doublet. They might balk at Lloyd’s irreverence and excesses. The director of “Sunset Boulevard” with Nicole Scherzinger always inspires polarizing reactions, though his first go at pure joy had a grin plastered to my face for most of two and a half hours.
The instinct to make troubles go away by throwing a big, memorable bash is plainly said right there in the play: “Be you blithe and bonny — converting all your sounds of woe into hey nonny, nonny.”
Or into “Work It” by Missy Elliott, such as the case may be.