Kalshi is warning that New York Attorney General Letitia James could force its entire prediction-market exchange to shutter nationwide as she seeks to crack down on the company’s alleged illegal gambling operations.
The dire warning came in a letter filed late Thursday by Kalshi’s attorneys at Milbank, just hours after a federal judge sent the company’s legal battle with James back to Manhattan Supreme Court, where the attorney general previously sought an emergency order to halt its operations.
Kalshi’s lawyers argued that the proposed order, which would bar contracts offered “within or from New York,” could effectively cripple the entire exchange because the company is headquartered in the Empire State — bringing in wagers tied to elections, sports and other events from across the country.
“There are serious defects in the ex parte relief previously sought by [James], including extraterritorial effects that extend well beyond this Court’s jurisdiction,” Kalshi’s lawyers wrote.
The letter was posted online by attorney Daniel Wallach.
Kalshi warned that the order could force it to shut down trades already placed by customers across the country, potentially throwing its trade into turmoil.
The company cited its $178 billion in annualized trading volume and $22 billion valuation as evidence of the stakes.
The company’s lawyers also pointed to an Aug. 11 order from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, which warned that a sudden shutdown could pose an “existential threat” to the exchange and cause major disruptions to wagers.
Kalshi argued that James has failed to establish the urgency needed for an emergency injunction, noting that the company has operated since July 2021 and offered sports-related contracts since January 2025 — more than a year before the attorney general filed her lawsuit.
New York gambling regulators issued Kalshi a cease-and-desist order in October 2025, prompting the company to sue in federal court.
In July, a Manhattan federal judge rejected Kalshi’s request to block the state from enforcing its gambling laws, a decision the company has appealed.
Kalshi is now urging Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Melissa Crane to schedule an immediate status conference and give the company an opportunity to challenge any renewed request for a temporary restraining order before it is issued.
James alleges that Kalshi is illegally operating a sports gambling business without a New York license, allowing customers as young as 18 to place bets despite the state’s minimum gambling age of 21.
The attorney general also accuses Kalshi of offering bets on sporting events involving New York college teams, which are prohibited under state law.
In Thursday’s ruling, US District Judge Vernon Broderick rejected Kalshi’s argument that its federal oversight by the CFTC entitled it to fight the lawsuit in federal court.
Broderick did not decide whether Kalshi’s contracts violate New York gambling laws, instead ruling that the dispute belongs in state court.
James previously sought a temporary restraining order without giving Kalshi an opportunity to argue against it, but the request was denied as moot after the company moved the lawsuit to federal court.
The state was allowed to renew its application once the case returned to Manhattan Supreme Court.
The Post has sought comment from Kalshi and James.